Sloppy data floods or precise social science methodologies? : Dilemmas in the transition to data-intensive research in sociology and economics


Levallois, Clément | STEINMETZ, Stéphanie | WOUTERS, Paul

Edité par MIT Press - 20121001

What are the implications of data-intensive research for social sciences? In an influential editorial, Chris Anderson from the magazine Wired predicted a future where scientific advances would result less from theoretical work, and more from brute force mining on petabytes of data. While evolutionary biology and astronomy are cited as two examples of fields which already entered this new age, it is very uncertain whether the social sciences should feel concerned at all by this prediction. This chapter chooses to examine the situation in two disciplines in particular - sociology and economics - to evaluate to what extent Anderson's claim applies to the social sciences. How is the emergence of new data sources perceived in these fields? Have different types of "big data" had different impacts? (transactional data for sociology, brain imaging data in economics). Is the diagnostic on the desirability of these changes unanimous among sociologists and economists? Comparing the debates and actual paths of research taken in these two cases, we observe that the coming of data intensive research does creates new trajectories renewing existing research practices, but with much more complexity than the sweeping change predicted. This lesson learned for social sciences suggests that a closer look at particular fields from natural sciences could possibly uncover similar, important nuances about the revolution supposedly brought by "big data" science.

  • anglais


Du même auteur

Translating upwards : linking the neural and social sciences via neuroeconomics | Levallois, Clément

Translating upwards : linking the neural and social sciences via neuroeconomics in Nature Reviews Neuroscience

Levallois, Clément ; CLITHERO, John A. ; WOUTERS, Paul ; SMIDTS, Ale ; HUETTEL, Scott A. , 20121101 - 789-797 P.


The social and neural sciences share a common interest in understanding the mechanisms that underlie human behaviour. However, interactions between neuroscience and social science disciplines remain strikingly narrow and tenuous. We illustrate the sc...

Aux origines de la scientométrie | Wouters, Paul

Aux origines de la scientométrie

Wouters, Paul


RésuméEn analysant la naissance du Science Citation Index (SCI), cet article montre que le principe consistant à indexer les citations n’est pas une création « naturelle » de l’univers scientifique ...

Source : CAIRN
Walking through a library remotely | Scharnhorst, Andrea

Walking through a library remotely

Scharnhorst, Andrea


There is no escape from the expansion of information, so that structuring and locating meaningful knowledge becomes ever more difficult. The question of how to order our knowledge is as old as the systematic acquisition, circulation, and storage of ...

Source : CAIRN
Chargement des enrichissements...

Avis des lecteurs