0 review

Why Were Biological Analogies in Economics "A Bad Thing"? : Edith Penrose's Battles against Social Darwinism and McCarthyism


Levallois, Clément

The heuristic value of evolutionary biology for economics is still much under debate. We suggest that in addition to analytical considerations, socio-cultural values can well be at stake in this issue. To demonstrate it, we use a historical case and focus on the criticism of biological analogies in the theory of the firm formulated by economist Edith Penrose in postwar United States. We find that in addition to the analytical arguments developed in her paper, she perceived that biological analogies were suspect of a conservative bias – as in social Darwinism. We explain this perception by documenting the broader context of Edith Penrose's personal and professional evolution, from her student days at Berkeley to her defense of Owen Lattimore against McCarthyism. We conclude that in the case under study at least, science and values were certainly intertwined in accounting for her skepticism towards biological analogies – insight we develop in the conclusion about today's relationships between biology and economics.


Du même auteur

Can de-growth be considered a policy option? : A historical note on Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen and the Club of Rome | Levallois, Clément

Can de-growth be considered a policy option? ...

Article | SYRACUSE | Levallois, Clément | 20100901

At a few months' interval, Georgescu-Roegen's The Entropy Law and the Economic Process (1971) and Club of Rome's Limits to Growth (1972) were published. Both emphasized the dangers of economic growth, and both drew negative reacti...

One Analogy Can Hide Another : Physics and Biology in Alchian's "Economic Natural Selection" | Levallois, Clément

One Analogy Can Hide Another : Physics and Bi...

Article | SYRACUSE | Levallois, Clément | 20090301

Today, Alchian's “Uncertainty, Evolution, and Economic Theory” (1950) is hailed by evolutionary economists as a most important piece that resumed an evolutionary brand of theorizing in economics after the eclipse of the interwar p...

Book Review: Foundations of Neuroeconomic Analysis, by Paul W. Glimcher | Levallois, Clément

Book Review: Foundations of Neuroeconomic Ana...

Article | SYRACUSE | Levallois, Clément | 20120101

Loading enrichments...

Reader reviews